Food for Thought
GRF Young Academics Policy Paper Series No.5 “State Responses to Cyber Operations”

Food for Thought

GRF Young Academics Policy Paper Series No.5 “State Responses to Cyber Operations”

20.09.2017
The fifth policy paper of the GRF Young Academics Program entitled "State Responses to Cyber Operations", which was designed to provide a forum for accomplished young academics to discuss and debate long-term policy challenges, was published.
Please click to read the paper authored by Dr. François Delerue.
Remembering Pekin Baran (1941 - 2023)GRF Global Outlook Report 2022 Is OutThe Global Relations Forum (GRF) - Industrial Development Bank of Turkey (TSKB) Joint Report Has Been Published.Global Relations Forum (GRF) - Centre for Economics and Foreign Policy Studies (EDAM) Joint Publication: "A Europe We Can Believe In"Open Position at Global Relations Forum: Administrative DirectorGRF Vice-Chairman and Former Director-General of the OPCW Ambassador (R) Ahmet Üzümcü Has Been Made An Honorary Companion of the Most Distinguished Order of St. Michael and St George.Chairperson of Güven Hospital and GRF Member Mrs. Nüket Küçükel Ezberci Awarded with the Italian ’’Cavaliere dell’Ordine della Stella d’Italia’’Prof. Füsun Türkmen, Professor of International Relations at Galatasaray University and GRF Member Awarded with the French "Chevalier de la Légion d’Honneur"Friends of Europe Article by GRF President Ambassador (R) Selim Yenel on the EU’s Role As a Global PlayerRemembering Sami Kohen (1928 - 2021)Dr. Fatih Birol, Executive Director of the International Energy Agency (IEA) and Founding Member of GRF, Has Been Chosen for TIME Magazine’s “World’s 100 Most Influential People in 2021”.New GRF Special Report: Roadmap for Turkey - European Union RelationsThe Council on Foreign Relations’ CoC Global Memo on the Latest G7 Meeting, With Contributions From GRF President Ambassador (R) Selim Yenel, Has Been Published.Article by Ambassador (R) Volkan Vural on His Memories of His Visit to ArmeniaArticle by Ambassador (R) Ahmet Üzümcü, Director-General of the Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW) and GRF Vice-Chairman, On His Memories and Observations Regarding Turkish-Armenian RelationsArticle By Ambassador (R) Erdoğan İşcan, Member of the UN Committee Against Torture and Lecturer at İstanbul Kültür University on the Legal Applicability of Genocide on the Armenian IssueArticle by Former Ambassador of Turkey to Washington, Ambassador (R) Namık Tan on the US-Turkey Armenian Genocide DebateOur Statement on Turkey’s Withdrawal From the Istanbul ConventionNew Global Relations Forum Publication: GİF Küresel Durum Raporu 2020The Council on Foreign Relations’ CoC Global Memo on the US Capitol Building Attack, With Contributions From GRF President Ambassador (R) Selim Yenel, Has Been Published.New Global Relations Forum Publication: Açık TelgrafRemembering Prof. Ahmet Acar (1949 - 2020)European Leadership Network (ELN) Article by GRF Members Formerly Serving as Permanent Representatives to NATO on the S-400 Crisis Now OnlineArticle by GRF President Ambassador (R) Selim Yenel Assessing the European Union’s Sanctions Policies with Regards to TurkeyArticle by Ambassador Bozkurt Aran, Director of the TEPAV Center for Multilateral Trade Studies and GRF Member, on the Regional Comprehensive Economic PartnershipGRF is Accepting Applications for a New Associate Position.The Council of Foreign Relations’ CoC Article Series on the US Elections, With Contributions From GRF President Ambassador (R) Selim Yenel, Has Been Published.GRF Honorary Member and Journalist Sami Kohen Awarded with ‘Distinguished Service Award’ of the Ministry of Foreign AffairsThe Council on Foreign Relations’ CoC Article on the UN, With Contributions From GRF President Ambassador (R) Selim Yenel, Has Been Published.GRF Public Appeal on Preserving the Istanbul ConventionArticle By Ambassador (R) Erdoğan İşcan, Member of the UN Committee Against Torture and Lecturer at İstanbul Kültür University on The United Nations Human Rights System During COVID-19GRF President Ambassador (R) Selim Yenel’s Article Has Been Published in the Council on Foreign Relations’ COVID-19 Article SeriesArticle by GRF Member Ambassador (R) Selim Kuneralp on the Customs Union and EU-Turkey RelationsAnnouncement: All Planned GRF Events for March Have Been Postponed Due to the CoronavirusSpeech by Permanent Representative of Turkey to the United Nations (F) and NATO, Ambassador Ümit Pamir on Global Governance and the Liberal OrderThe GRF Viewpoint Article from GRF President Ambassador (R) Selim Yenel on the EU-Turkey Migration Deal Has Been Published by Friends of EuropeArticle by NATO Permanent Representative (F) and GRF Member Ambassador (R) Fatih Ceylan on NATO’s Strategy in the Middle EastGRF Board Member Ambassador Ahmet Üzümcü Awarded with "The Most Distinguished Order of St. Michael and St. George" Honorary AwardEuropean Think Tanks Reflect on the Challenges of Emerging Military TechnologiesExcerpt from Per. Representative of Turkey to WTO (F) and Director of Trade Studies at TEPAV, Ambassador Bozkurt Aran’s Article About Trump’s Trade Wars on Turkish Policy QuarterlyExcerpt from Permanent Representative (F) of Turkey to the United Nations and to NATO, Ambassador Ümit Pamir’s Interview with Daily HürriyetGRF Board Member, İşbank CEO, Mr. Adnan Bali’s Assessments on the Turkish Economy and the Speculative Attacks Targeting the TLThe Task Force on Cooperation in Greater Europe’s Position Paper Entitled “Towards a NATO-Russia Basic Understanding” Has Been PublishedGRF Board Member Ambassador Ertuğrul Apakan Awarded with the French “Officier dans l’Ordre National de la Légion d’Honneur"GRF Vice-Chairperson Mrs. Hanzade Doğan Boyner Delivers a Speech at the UN during the International Day of Women and Girls in ScienceDr. Fatih Birol Re-elected as the Executive Director of the International Energy Agency (IEA)Article from Permanent Representative of Turkey to WTO (F), Director of Trade Studies at TEPAV and Board Member at Şişecam, Ambassador (R) Bozkurt Aran, published by the Bretton Woods ComitteeExcerpt from Permanent Representative (F) of Turkey to the United Nations and to NATO, Ambassador Ümit Pamir’s Interview with Daily HürriyetExcerpt from MIT Undersecretary (F) Ambassador Sönmez Köksal’s Interview with Daily HürriyetGRF Young Academics Policy Paper Series No.5 “State Responses to Cyber Operations”Declaration on the JCPOAGlobal Perspectives: Rapid Reactions to U.S. Election Results - Memos by Council of Councils MembersGlobalization, European Union and Economic Integration - Ambassador (R) Bozkurt AranGRF Young Academics Policy Paper Series No.4 “The Russian-Turkish Rapprochement: Policy Options for Ankara and its Allies”Migration as a Challenge to Regional Security - Ambassador (R) Ümit PamirThe Referendum Heralds a New Europe - Ambassador (R) Ünal ÇeviközEUʼs Crisis or the Supranational Governance Utopia - Ambassador (R) Özdem SanberkGRF Young Academics Policy Paper Series No.3 - “Turkeyʼs Foreign Policy Towards China, Analysis and Recommendations for Improvement”EU Energy Policy: Sustained by Fragile Solidarity, Indispensable for Eurasian Security - Memduh KarakullukçuGRF Board Member Prof. İlter Turan Elected President of the International Political Science Association (IPSA)GRF Board Member Prof. Gülsün Sağlamer Became the First President of European Women Rectors Association (EWORA)GRF Member Prof. Orhan Güvenen Recieved Award from the Academy of Transdisciplinary Learning & Advanced Studies“The Mashriq Crisis: Containing Waves of Instability” Meeting ReportGRF – CFR Council of Councils 8th Regional Meeting Rapporteurs’ ReportGRF Young Academics Policy Paper Series No.2 - “Pipeline Partners: Expanding and Securing Iraqʼs Future Oil Exports”GRF – Club of Three “Working Session on Turkey and Europe” Meeting ReportGRF Founding Member Dr. Fatih Birol was appointed as the next Executive Director of the International Energy Agency (IEA)GRF Chairman Mr. Rahmi Koç Awarded with the French “Légion d’Honneur”Council of Councils’ (CoC) Meeting on Crisis in Global Governance and International Cooperation Report Card LaunchGRF Security Task Force Report entitled "Turkey in a Changing Global and Regional Security Environment: Some Observations and Recommendations" has been publishedLaunch Meetings of GRF Security Task Force Report entitled “Turkey in a Changing Global and Regional Security Environment: Some Observations and Recommendations”GRF-ISD “Club of Three Plenary of Turkey and its Neighbours” Meeting ReportGRF Founding Member Dr. Fatih Birol Appointed as the next Executive Director of the International Energy Agency (IEA)Managing the Interaction between Islam and Democracy - Özdem SanberkTechnology, Democracy and Rights - Speech Delivered by GRF Vice-Chairman and President Mr. Memduh Karakullukçu at 4th Asian Forum on Global GovernanceGRF Young Academics Policy Paper Series No.1 - “Turkey in the Eurasian Energy Game”India Global Forum 2014 ParticipationGRF Board Member Mrs. Suzan Sabancı Dinçer has Received the “Order of Civil Merit” of the Kingdom of SpainGRF Vice-Chairwoman Mrs. Hanzade Doğan Boyner Named as “Role Model” by the Girl Effect MovementThe New Vision of the "New Turkey" - Özdem SanberkGRF MemberAmbassador Ertuğrul ApakanHeads OSCE Special Monitoring Mission to UkraineGRF Member Prof. Selçuk Esenbel Has Received the "Georg Forster Research Award"GRF Vice President Memduh Karakullukcu’s Speech at the Observer Research FoundationGRF Member Prof. Orhan Güvenen has Received the "Gusi Peace Prize" -An Academy for Global Civics - Hakan AltınayGlobal Partnership Quests: New Contentious Dynamics in Trade and Prospects For Turkey in an Age of TPP and TTIP - Bozkurt AranLaunching Meeting of “Turkish Energy Strategy in the 21st Century: Weathering Uncertainties and Discontinuities” ReportThe Balkans and Turkey - Foreign Policy and Defence Research Group (DSA)Geopolitical Earthquakes - Sönmez KöksalG-20: Some Ideas for the Russian Presidency and Beyond - Speech Delivered by Mr. Memduh Karakullukçu, Vice-Chairman and President of GRFPolicy Understanding of Economic Globalization - Diana Mutz and Edward D. MansfieldA Light in the Forest: Brazil’s Fight to Save the Amazon and Climate-Change DiplomacyJeff TollefsonThe Inequality Challenge Uri Dadush and Kemal DervişBroken BRICs: Why the Rest Stopped Rising - Ruchir SharmaTurkey-USA Relations: Fragile Alliance to “Model Partnership” - Associate Prof. Füsun TürkmenBucking Beijing: An Alternative U.S. China Policy - Aaron L. FriedbergUK-Turkey Knowledge Partnership DiscussionHow India Stumbled: Can New Delhi Get Its Groove Back? - Pratap Bhanu Mehta  OECD Conference on Internationalisation for Job Creation and Economic Growth - Speech Delivered by Mr. Memduh Karakullukçu, Vice-Chairman and President of GRFObama’s New Global Posture: The Logic of U.S. Foreign Deployments - Michele Flournoy and Janine DavidsonAddressing the Turkish Dimension in Creating a Euro-Atlantic Security Community - Euro-Atlantic Security Initiative (EASI) The Iran Crisis: Imperatives of Immediacy, Perils of Systemic Corrosion - Memduh KarakullukçuNATO is Still Fit for the Job and Continuous Adaptation is the Right Call for It - Ümit PamirThe Future of History: Can Liberal Democracy Survive the Decline of the Middle Class? - Francis FukuyamaSyrian-Iraqi-Iranian Triangle to Leave Turkey on Slippery Slope - Sönmez KöksalIs Indonesia Bound for the BRICs?: How Stalling Reform Could Hold Jakarta Back - Karen BrooksHow to Save the Euro—and the EU: Reading Keynes in Brussels - Henry Farrell and John QuigginThe Post-Washington Consensus: Development After the Crisis - Nancy Birdsall and Francis FukuyamaA G-Zero World: The New Economic Club Will Produce Conflict, Not Cooperation - Ian Bremmer and Nouriel RoubiniPolicy Paper entitled "Turkey and Turmoil in the Middle East"Turkey Is Losing Hope of a Rapport with Israel - Ozdem SanberkIrresponsible Stakeholders? The Difficulty of Integrating Rising Powers - Stewart PatrickThe Digital Disruption: Connectivity and the Diffusion of Power - Eric Schmidt and Jared CohenU.S. Aid to Pakistan: Time for a New Approach - Homi KharasGDP and Economic Policy - Roya WolversonGetting Energy Regulation Right - John P. BanksBigger Is Better: - The Case for a The Case for a Transatlantic Economic Union - Richard RosecranceAnd Justice for All - Gary Haugen and Victor BoutrosCoping With China’s Financial Power - Ken MillerWhich Europe?: - The Future of the EU - Özdem SanberkU.S. Alliances in East Asia: Internal Challenges and External Threats - William BreerObamaʼs New Nuclear Policies: A Step in the Right Direction - Michael E. OʼHanlonIndia’s Rise, America’s Interest The Fate of the U.S.-Indian Partnership - Evan A. FeigenbaumVicious Circle Of National Narratives - Özdem SanberkFrom Hope to Audacity - Zbigniew BrzezinskiSearching For A Settlement In Southeastern Turkey -Are Davos Manʼs Days Numbered? - Raj M. Desai & James Raymond VreelandThree Keys to Understanding Japan’s New Diplomacy - Keike IizukaIranʼs Ballistic Missile Program - Greg Bruno